There is much cause for concern surrounding the radical reduction in bus services to the areas between Knowle and Dorridge which were introduced in February when the weekday half hourly S2 and S3 services were replaced by the hourly A7/8 and A3 services respectively.
There was but one cause of cheer. That is the replacement of operator. Rotala’s Diamond service has been poor, with indifferent timekeeping, buses that have not turned up at all, high driver turnover and substandard vehicles being frequent issues.
The ‘Signature’ specifications, presumably promised to win the contract, were quickly lost. On board wifi rarely worked, in vehicle information displays quickly failed and were never repaired. It can only be hoped that the new operator, Landflight, does better.
It is, however, surely unacceptable that the service’s commissioners, Transport for West Midlands, gave no advance indication of this radical service frequency reduction. In fact, the reverse is the case. In running their October consultation about proposed changes, TfWM misled our community when in the introduction to the consultation document, it wrote:
“We have looked at the numbers of passengers travelling on routes, requests from councillors and customers, new developments, reliability of the services and any forthcoming proposed changes to commercial routes run by operators, in order to create a better and smarter tendered bus network.
“We are keen to highlight that we are not looking to reduce the support for bus services across the borough. We are looking at how we can use that support to give the best possible service to all residents in the area, whilst pursuing opportunities to grow and develop the network further.”
This reassured us that the services to the area would be protected. Now, the halving of the daytime service has only come to light a week ago when Landflight published the new timetables on their website, leaving no time to make any effective challenge to the decisions.
I know from my own use of the current S3 service that there are some significant issues with the new A3 timetables can be expected. Just as examples:
- A busy time of day for the service is mid to late afternoon, but there are to be significant gaps between the three services leaving Solihull Town Centre at 15:19, 16:41 and 17:50, just three buses between 2.30pm and 6.30pm.
- This can be expected affect a few Solihull School pupils who regularly catch the bus back to stops between Knowle and Dorridge, with the end of school day at 15:30, as well as shoppers looking to beat the end of work rush.
- There are a number of regulars of the final couple of services which currently leave the Town Centre at about 22:10 and 23:10 with a new last bus time changing to 20:50, these people will be left with only expensive taxi services as their route home.
There were 30 S3 services leaving Solihull for Dorridge per weekday. This has changed to just 13 A3 services. There were 25 S2 services leaving Solihull for Dorridge per weekday. This became just 15 of the new A7/A7W ‘Clockwise’ services (with the same number of A8/A8W running the reverse direction). See the new Timetables for more details.
This represents a poor frequency level to serve an area approaching 10,000 homes.
The promised ‘better and smarter bus network’ this is not. When we are seeking to encourage greater use of public transport and less reliance on the car – this seems very much a step in the wrong direction!
