The Casualty List Grows Still

Judy Garland - Wizard of Oz

Streaming Judy and marvelling at Renée Zellweger’s bravura performance last night was pre-planned chez nous. What was unexpected was assimilating the news beforehand of the loss to the entertainment world of Caroline Flack. There was a stark and sad irony, inevitably comparing and contrasting Judy and Caroline, two performers at the forefront of their profession, much loved and appreciated by the public, falling tragically from grace and dying needlessly young.

Beside that lie another irony, with ITV broadcasting in parallel the final of its Masked Singer, starring Caroline’s peers in the world of reality TV, notably Joel Dommett, with whom she had time served in the ‘Get Me Out Here Now!’ studio in common, and Davina McCall, who had done for Big Brother what Caroline later achieved with the massive success of Love Island.

Yet the very concept, the Masked Singer, belies the certainty that those we applaud as the stars of reality entertainment are all wearing masks, just ones that are unseen. They put on the cloak of confidence, façade of familiarity and veil of vigour without which no-one could succeed on the stage, to hide the insecurities, pressures and turmoil that sit in the background troubling so many who have been driven to seek public acclamation on a stage.

It is small wonder, in our modern times, that the cracks show when the adoring fans turn instead to an appetite for the salacious and sometime speculative venom peddled by the Daily Dishrags and then  indulge themselves in Trial by Twitter. Collectively, we build the stars up and cheer their triumph and then turn the spotlight through 180 degrees to soak up the news of downward spirals behind their scenes, whether real or invented (small wonder the speculation that Oti Mabuse may quit Strictly for the sake of her sanity after the past week).

The casualty list of reality TV lives ended or blighted extends at an alarming rate and the roll call of celebrities taking a tragic final curtain grows longer. The question has to be asked – actors, pop stars, presenters and participants are well paid to capture our hearts when the lights go up but is enough being done to protect their welfare when the cameras switch off and the masks are removed?